Select from Menu

How To Field Judge for Trophy Elk

Elk Photo
by Craig R. Watkins Image Couresy of USDA

Indisputably, one of the world's greatest trophy big-game animals is the bull elk.  A trophy bull elk is a very impressive sight.  One of the most outstanding features of the bull elk is its antler formation, and it is the elks antler formation that determines its trophy value.

Naturally, a trophy can mean different things to us at different times.  Perhaps you have hunted hard for weeks, only bagging a small elk that will help feed your family for the year.  Of course, to you that could still be considered a trophy because of the time and energy you dedicated to harvesting the animal.  But, to the keepers of the Boone & Crocket™ or Pope & Young™ record books of North American big game, the word "trophy" designates an animal that exceeds the club's minimum entry standards.   An animal "which has usually been won by persistence, great effort, and accurate shooting."

Here are some tips that will help you better judge and harvest that record bull elk in the woods.

Often, we happen upon a large bull first.  We get excited and shoot it, only to find out that there were three larger bulls in the area.  Unless you happen to come upon an especially large bull that would have a score as high as you are looking for, don't shoot the first bull you see.

Look for a bull with a 6 x 6 point rack or larger.  Over 90% of the bulls in the record book have a 6 x 6 point rack or larger.  It isn't so much the number which distinguishes the splendid trophy as the length and spread of the rack.  Look for six or more points which sweep upwards with main beams of at least 40 inches.  Check for thick beams, particularly from near the base to the fourth or primary points.  Big elk are around 24 inches wide at the chest.  Each side of his rack should extend at least five inches on each side of his body.

Sizing up a bull on the move is not an easy task.  Evaluation is much easier, when the bull lowers his head to graze, because the antlers tip up somewhat.  The main beam's length should be as tall as the bull at his shoulders or taller.  When the head is held high the antlers should extend beyond the rib cage.  I use the 40-40 rule: rack must be 40 inches tall and 40 inches on the inside spread or higher.

Look for long symmetrical points which are at least nine inches or longer.  As with deer, there will be deductions for any differences in the racks.

Measurements that count
when scoring a bull:
Inside Spread: The widest point at a right angle to main beams must not exceed length at the  longest main beams.
Length of Points: Left side and right side.  Any differences will be deducted.
Circumference: Circumference at smallest points between:
  1st & 2nd Points
  2nd & 3rd Points
  4th & 5th Points
  These are taken on left and right antlers and any differences are subtracted.

Bull Elk Scoring Examples

Bull 1 - a 6 x 6
Score

395 4/8

Length of Main Beams
Right

56 2/8

Left

51 2/8

Inside Spread

43 6/8

Circumference at Smallest Place Between First & Second Points
Right

10 2/8

Left

10 2/8

 
Bull 2 - a 6 x 6
Score

375

Length of Main Beams
Right

52 6/8

Left

52 5/8

Inside Spread

47 4/8

Circumference at Smallest Place Between First & Second Points
Right

8 6/8

Left

9

© Craig R. Watkins
This article first appeared in the Smoke Signals™ newsletter.

backbutton.gif (193 bytes) Back to Hunting Related Articles

 

Copyright ©1999-2006
The Hunter's Network All Rights Reserved.
Please click here for legal restrictions
and terms of use applicable to this site. 
Use of this site signifies your agreement to the terms of use
 

Base Camp ] About Us ] Contact Us ] Related Sites ]

Copyright ©1999-2008 The Hunter's Network All Rights Reserved.

Please click here for legal restrictions and terms of use applicable to this site.  Use of this site signifies your agreement to the terms of use.